Are Automatic Litter Boxes Safe? An In-Depth Analysis

Cats are quirky, loveable, and cuddly little creatures. Sure, they can be a little mischievous, running around, causing some trouble here and there, but that’s what makes them so adorable, right?

But as much as we love our fur babies, scooping their litter isn’t exactly our favorite way to spend time with them. The solution? An automatic litter box.

Like most things, the modern litter box has evolved from a traditional pan into something entirely automated and self-sufficient. The latter has become a huge hit with cat parents for the obvious reasons of ease and convenience. But one thing rests on our minds as we make the shift into the unknown world of “cat tech”, just how safe are these things? Let’s do a deep dive and find out.

For Starters, Automatic Litter Boxes May Not Be For All Cats!

As cat parents continue to switch to automatic litter boxes the issue of acclimation becomes overwhelmingly apparent. Some folks are still a bit hesitant to make the change from what feels familiar, let’s investigate that parallel to how our cats may be feeling.

You can’t quite blame buyers for being a little hesitant about it. There have been quite a few catastrophic stories in the press about cattails getting stuck in rotating litter devices.

As a cat owner, one story alone is enough to keep you from taking the plunge. But not all automatic litter boxes are created equal in that regard.

Self-cleaning litter boxes aren’t for every cat, this is true. Every automatic litter box is different and so are the behaviors of the cats that use them.

Some cats prefer enclosed boxes, while others don’t like a covered unit. Some cats can also startle easily from the noise of the larger units, making them not want to use it at all. Some need a lower unit better suited for seniors and special needs cats while others are just fine making a high hop into the bathroom. The key is to find the right fit that offers both safety and an ideal acclimation for your kitty.

You know your fur babies better than anyone, so let’s take a look into which units offer the best features for your fur family!

The Pros And Cons

How to find the safest self-cleaning litter box for your cat. With a variety of brands available in the market, it can be hard to find which one offers the most clear-cut design to keep your cat safe and happy. Oh, if you could only test each one, that would be a perfect solution but hey, self-cleaning litter boxes aren’t exactly the cheapest items for “trial run”.

They can range anywhere from $100 up to $600+! But if you’re someone who wants the world for your cat (not to mention you’ll spare yourself the back pain in the long run) you might be ready to take a chance and see what’s available to you. Automatic litter box brands using a traditional rotating mechanism have held consistent popularity among consumers. Rotating machines are some of the top choices in terms of overall functionality.

They are well equipped with sensor technology that detects when your cat is inside, doing their business, and then cleans automatically by separating the soiled litter from the clean litter. Through a system of back and forth rotations these devices shift to separate and trap all the clumps into a waste drawer directly underneath the unit.

Keeping things hassle-free and as sanitary as possible. Alright, we’ve heard the good now let’s hear the bad. As these units are some of the larger in the lot they do present a compatibility issue for allowing seniors, kittens, and special needs cats easy access to the entryway. But that’s not the downfall of rotating devices.

Different from the non-traditional horizontal systems, which tend to work much slower, these things have the potential to get a little aggressive in terms of cycle and noise. Disrupting the overall bathroom process and discouraging acclimation can be a bit of a long term concern for our kitties.

What About Horizontal Systems?

This is where units like the AutoEgg by ChillX or the ScoopFree by PetSafe offer a non-traditional approach. Using a raking system these units will initiate a cleaning following each use to slowly and gently sift through the litter bed to redeposit waste into their given compartments.

Just like every other unit on the market, these too come with well-designed safety features that use a combination of weight and motion detection to make sure the process takes a pause upon entry.

The safest part? They’re SLOW. Not in a bad way, since these guys work round the clock the pace isn’t an issue as long as the job gets done. But what does that mean in regards to their safety? Even in the unlikely event that the safety features were to fail these units move slow enough that the odds of your cat getting trapped or injury within the unit are pretty slim.

They also work to the advantage of accessibility. Both units are relatively low to the ground making entry a much easier process for cats who need something with a lower entryway.

Our downside to the pace would be most attributed to having to wait for a cleaning cycle to finish up over a 5 to 10 minute period. However, since both units offer hooded options there’s not much to see nor complain about if it means our fur babies are safe and sound.

How About An Alternative System?

As mentioned, automatic litter boxes seem to range quite a bit design wise. One of the more interesting methods of cleaning we can attribute to the CatGenie. This is a totally unique method which uses a system of flushable litter. CatGenie uses reusable, washable litter granules, promoting an eco-friendly cleaning concept.

It’s.. it’s a toilet? Sort of!

After a bathroom trip the device washes (flushes) away the waste, cleans the litter thoroughly and then dries it so it’s ready for the next use.

Essentially the system works similar to any other toilet but more or less it’s like a washing machine for your litter (it even requires a cold water line connection).

In terms of safety we can’t really fault the CatGenie, although there aren’t any ultra-specific safety features it’s an open-air top and removes most of the elements of sifting the litter since it actually works to cleanse the litter.

An eco-friendly option for sure, our only concern is for your drainage system if those pellets slip down. Although they’re listed as biodegradable, reports tell us that cat owners can be looking at one heck of a hefty bill if those pile up in your pipes.


Most automated litter boxes are designed to be as safe as possible. The unlikely event of an accident shouldn’t deter you from moving forward so long as you make the best decision for a unit that fits your cat’s needs.

Some litter boxes can be too loud and discourage the acclimation process. Some are too tall for your cat to even hop into. Some just move at a glacial pace when all you want is for the job to get done!

Whether you’re drawn to a rotating device or a non-traditional horizontal approach or even a cat toilet the decision is ultimately yours to make.

Although our cats can be very self-sufficient creatures they’re always gonna need their fur family to keep an eye out to make sure they’re safe and content.

So weigh your options, ease into the world of hassle-free cleaning with an automatic litter box and make the decision based on how well you think each unit works to protect your cat from harm’s way.

Automated litter boxes are a safe, easy, and odor-free solution for the modern pet owner.

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
You Might Also Like:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *